Meeting Minutes
November 2002
The IPv6 working group held two
working group meetings
at the IETF meeting held in Atlanta
on November 18 & 22,2002.
The minutes were taken
by Bob Hinden, Margaret Wasserman, and Sharon Chisholm.
- Introduction and Agenda Bashing (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Bob Hinden
- Document Status and Priorities (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Margaret Wasserman
- Proposed Charter Update (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Margaret Wasserman
- MIB Updates (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Margaret Wasserman
- Prefix Delegation Requirements (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Shin Miyakawa
- DHCP Option for Prefix Delegation (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Ralph Droms
- Flow Label (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Jarno Rajahalme
- Node Requirements (
pdf
) (
ppt
), John Loughney
- Introduction to Site-Local Usage (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Bob Hinden
- Site Local (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Rich Draves
- Routing & Forwarding of Site Local Addresses (
pdf
), Brian Haberman
- Connected Site- Local Considered Harmful (
pdf
), Rob Austein
- Moderate Site-Local Usage (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Bob Hinden
- Well known site local unicast addresses to communicate
with recursive DNS servers (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Alain Durand
- Issues with DHCPv6 (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Ralph Droms
- IPv6 over Fibre Channel (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Claudio DeSanti
July 2002
The IPv6 working group held two
working group meetings
at the IETF meeting held in Yokohama
on July 18.
The minutes were taken
and edited by Bob Hinden and Margaret Wasserman.
- Introduction, Agenda, Priorities and Status (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Steve Deering & Bob Hinden
- IPv6 MIBs Status and Open Issues (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Margaret Wasserman
- IPv6 Node Requirements (
pdf
) (
ppt
), John Loughney
- DAD vs. DIID Discussion (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Chairs
- Addressing Architecture Open Issues (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Bob Hinden
- Default Address Selection Open Issues (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Rich Draves
- DNS Discovery Status and Next Steps
- Area Director Feedback (
pdf
), Erik Nordmark
- IPv6 Chairs (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Margaret Wasserman
- Prefix Delegation
- Prefix Delegation Requirements (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Shin Miyakawa
- IPv6 W.G. Chairs (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Margaret Wasserman
- Node Information Queries Status & IESG Feedback (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Bob Hinden
- Node Information Queries for Reverse DNS Lookup (
pdf
) (
ps
), Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino
- Flow Label (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Jarno Rajahalme
- Scoped Address Architecture (
pdf
), Tatuya Jinmei
- IPv6 Anycast Architecture (
pdf
) (
ps
), Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino
- A Protocol for Anycast Address Resolving (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Shingo Ata
- Issues in IPv6 Deployment/Operation (
pdf
), Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino or Tatuya Jinmei
- Link Scoped IPv6 Multicast (
pdf
) (
ppt
), Jung-Soo Park
March 2002
The IPv6 working group held a
working group meeting
at the IETF meeting held in Minneapolis
on March 18 and 21, 2002.
The minutes were taken
and edited by Bob Hinden and Margaret Wasserman.
- Introduction, Announcements, Review Agenda, Document Status (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Steve Deering & Bob Hinden
- Moving IPv6 Documents to Draft Standard (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Margaret Wasserman
- Default Router Preferences and More-Specific Routes (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Rich Draves
- DNS Discovery Update (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Dave Thaler
- IPv6 Node Requirements (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, John Loughney
- Minimum IPv6 Functionality for a Cellular Host (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Hesham Soliman
- Minimum Requirements of IPv6 for Low Cost Network Appliances (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Atsushi Inoue
- IPv6 Node Requirements follow up (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, John Loughney
- Prefix Delegation Introduction (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Steve Deering
- Automatic Prefix Delegation Protocol for IPV6 (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Jim Martin
- DHCPv6 Prefix Delegation (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Ralph Droms
- IPv6 Router Advertisement Prefix Delegation Option (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Nathan Lutchansky (given by Steve Deering)
- Prefix Delegation Discussion (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Steve Deering
- IPv6 Flow Label Specification (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Jarno Rajahalme
- Reserving bits in RFC 2473 Interface IDs? (
pdf
)
, Erik Nordmark
- Make IMEI-based universal IPv6 interface IDs a w.g. Draft? (
pdf
)
, Francis Dupont
- Scoped Address Architecture Update (
pdf
)
, Tatuya Jinmei
- Allocating bit in IID for Mobile IPv6 (
pdf
)
, Erik Nordmark
December 2001
The IPv6 working group held a
working group meeting
at the IETF meeting held in Salt Lake City
on December 11 & 13, 2001.
The minutes were taken
and edited by Bob Hinden.
- Introduction, Review Agenda, Document Status (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Steve Deering & Bob Hinden
- Default Address Selection for IPv6 (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Brian Zill
- Default Router Preferences and More-Specific Routes (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Brian Zill
- IPv6 Host to Router Load Sharing (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Bob Hinden
- Redundant Address Deletion when Encapsulating IPv6 in IPv6 (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Steve Deering
- Scoped Address Architecture (
pdf
)
, Tatuya Jinmei
- An IPv6 Flow Label Specification Proposal (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Jarno Rajahalme
- DNS Discovery Problem Statement Review (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Steve Deering
- DNS Discovery Update (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Dave Thaler
- Using DHCPv6 for DNS Configuration in Hosts (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Ralph Droms
- Recommendations for IPv6 in 3GPP Standards (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Margaret Wasserman
- Minimum IPv6 Functionality for a Cellular Host (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, John Loughney
- IPv6 minimum host requirement for low cost network appliances (
pdf
)
, Nobuo Okabe
- Threat Analysis for IPv6 Public Multi-Access Links (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, James Kempf
- Advanced API (
pdf
)
, Tatuya Jinmei
- Host-based IPv6 Multicast Addresses Allocation (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Jung-Soo Park
August 2001
The IPng working group held an
working group meeting
at the IETF meeting held in London
on August 8 and 10, 2001.
The minutes were taken
and edited by Bob Hinden.
- Introduction, Document Status, and Charter Status (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Steve Deering & Bob Hinden
- 3GPP-IETF Design team status (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Bob Hinden
- Requirements for IPv6 dialup operation (
pdf
) (
ps
)
, Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino
- Avoiding ping-pong packets on point-to-point links (
pdf
) (
ps
)
, Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino
- Multilink Subnets (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Dave Thaler
- DHCPv6 Status and Last Call (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Ralph Droms
- Minimum IPv6 Functionality for a Cellular Host (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, John Loughney
- AAAv6 Status (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Charlie Perkins
- Ad-Host Interoperability Test Report (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Brian Zill
- IPv6 Site Renumbering (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Christian Huitema
- Source and Destination Address Selection (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Brian Zill
- Domain Name Auto-Registration for Plugged-in IPv6 Nodes (
pdf
)
, Hiroshi Kitamura
- A proposal for the IPv6 Flow Label Specification (
pdf
)
, Alex Conta
- DNS Discovery (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Dave Thaler
- An analysis of IPv6 anycast (
pdf
) (
ps
)
, Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino
- Disconnecting TCP connection toward IPv6 anycast address (
pdf
) (
ps
)
, Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino
- IPv6 MIB Update Status (
pdf
)
, Bill Fenner
- Socket API for IPv6 traffic class field (
pdf
) (
ps
)
, Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino
- Status of Linux and USAGI IPv6 (
pdf
)
, Yuji Sekiya
May/June 2001
The IPng working group held an
interim meeting
in Redmond, Washington, US.
on May 30, 31, and June 1, 2001. The first day of the meeting was joint
with 3GPP. The meeting was hosted by Microsoft. The minutes were taken
and edited by Bob Hinden.
- Introduction (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Steve Deering & Bob Hinden
- Local Arrangements (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Christian Huitema
- 3GPP Architecture (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Jonne Soininen
- 3GPP2 Overview (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Pat Calhoun
- Multi-Link Subnets (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Dave Thaler
- Router Selection (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Rich Draves
- Ingress Filtering (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Rich Draves
- Dialup Architecture (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino
- Comments on Address Selection Last Call (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Rich Draves
- Updates to Addressing Architecture (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Bob Hinden
- DNS Discovery (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Dave Thaler
March 2001
The IPng working group held
two working group sessions
on
March 19 and 22, 2001
at the Minneapolis IETF Meeting.
The minutes were taken and edited by Bob Hinden
- Introduction and Document Status (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Bob Hinden
- IPv6 Addressing Documents Issues and Status (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Thomas Narten
- Source/Destination Address Selection (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Rich Draves
- Default Router Preferences & More Specific Routes in RAs (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Rich Draves
- MIB Design Team Report (
ps
) (
pdf
)
, Bill Fenner
- An analysis of IPv6 anycast (
pdf
) (
ps
)
, Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino
- Host-based Anycast using MLD (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Brian Haberman
- Site prefixes in Neighbor Discovery (
ps
) (
pdf
)
, Erik Nordmark
- Generic Packet Tunneling in IPv6 - Bi-directional Tunneling (
pdf
), Alex Conta
- IPv6 Scoped Address Architecture (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Steve Deering
- IPv6 Near-Unique Site-Local Addresses (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Paul Francis
- DNS Server Discovery Mechanisms for IPv6 Update (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Dave Thaler
- Multicast Listener Discovery Version 2 (MLDv2) for IPv6 Multicast
Listener Discovery Version 2 (MLDv2) for IPv6 (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Luis Costa
- IPv6 Flow Label Track
-
End-to-End Flow IPv6 Flow Label
(
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Steve Deering
- Redefining the IPv6 Flow Label (
pdf
)
, Alex Conta
December 2000
The IPng working group held
two working group sessions
on
December 13 and 14, 2000
at the San Diego IETF.
The minutes were taken and edited by Bob Hinden
- Document Status and Charter Status (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Bob Hinden
- Summary of Internet Address Registry Presentations (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Alain Durand
- Source and Destination Address Selection (
ppt
) (
pdf
)
, Rich Draves
- An analysis of IPv6 anycast (
pdf
) (
ps
)
, Itojun Hagino
- Analysis of DNS Server Discovery Mechanisms for IPv6 (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Dave Thaler
- Discovery of Resource Records Designating IPv6 Address prefixes (
pdf
) (
ps
)
, Matt Crawford
- Socket API for IPv6 traffic class field (
pdf
) (
ps
)
, Itojun Hagino
- Default Router Preferences & More Specific Routes in RAs (
ppt
) (
pdf
)
, Rich Draves
- Automatic Prefix Delegation Protocol for IPv6 (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Brian Haberman
- Destination Option Headers Cleanup (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Francis Dupont
- An end-to-end usage of IPv6 flow label (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Jochen Metzler
- Socket API for IPv6 flow label field
, Itojun Hagino
[Combined with Socket API for IPv6 traffic class field presentation]
- End-to-End Multihoming (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Masataka Ohta
- Record Route Hop-by-Hop Option for IPv6 (
pdf
)
, Hiroshi Kitamura
- ETSI bake-off report (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Francis Dupont
- Overview of USAGI Project
, Sekiya
- Site renumbering using router renumbering protocol (
pdf
)
, Tatuya Jinmei
- How to write UDP IPv6 applications that care about path MTU (
pdf
), Tatuya Jinmei
- Status of OSPFv3 implementation for Zebra (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Yasuhiro Ohara
- LIN6: Mobility Support in IPv6 based on End-to-End Communication Model (
pdf
) (
ppt
)
, Fumio Teraoka
November 1999
The IPng working group held
two working group sessions
on
November 10 and 11, 1999
at the Washington, DC IETF.
The minutes were taken and edited by Allison Mankin and Bob Hinden.
- Introduction and Document Status(
pdf
), B. Hinden, S. Deering
- DNS A6 Record (
pdf
), M. Crawford
- ICMP Lookups (
pdf
), M. Crawford
- IPv6 extensions to RPC (
pdf
)(
ppt
), S. Majee
- TAHI Project Interoperability test event in Tokyo (
pdf
)(
ppt
), H. Miyata
- Privacy Issues w/ Addrconf (
pdf
)(
ps
), Anonymous
- Wireless Telephony (
pdf
)(
ps
), C. Perkins
- Connection/Link Status Investigation (CSI) (
pdf
), H. Kitamura
- Unidirectional Link Routing (
pdf
)(
ppt
), H. Afifi
- Text Syntax for Scoped Addresses (
pdf
)(
ppt
), T. Jinmei
- Source Address Selection Draft (
pdf
)(
ppt
), R. Draves
- IPv6 Inverse Neighbor Discovery (
pdf
)(
ppt
), A. Conta
- Local Scope IPv6 Networking (
pdf
), B. Hinden, [Talk not given]
September/October 1999
The IPng working group held a
two and half day meeting
on
September 29 - October 1, 1999
in Tokyo.
Presentations from the meeting:
- Introduction (
pdf
), B. Hinden, S. Deering
- IPv6 Address Scoping Model, From A Node's Point of View (
pdf
), S. Deering
- Overview of IP(v6) Multihoming Issues (
pdf
), S. Deering
- Source Address Selection and Destination Address Ordering (
pdf
), R. Draves
- Multihoming, Policy, and Home Networks (
pdf
), G. Tsirtsis
- Multihoming with Router Renumbering (
pdf
), G. Tsirtsis
- Update on Longest Prefix Match (
pdf
), A. Durand
- Mobility Useage (
slide-1 pdf
)
)(
slide-2 pdf
), F. Dupont
- IPv6 Site Renumbering (
pdf
), B. Hinden
- Multihoming in IPv6, Clever Exit Router Approach
(
pdf
)(
ps
), Itojun Hagino
- Multihoming API Issues (
pdf
), E. Nordmark
- Preserving Active TCP Sessions (
pdf
), P. Tattam
- Scope and Multihoming API Issues (
pdf
), E. Nordmark
- IPv6 Plug and Play Architecture? (
pdf
), S. Deering
- IIJ IPv6 Trial Service (
pdf
) (
ps), Itojun Hagino
- Meeting Network Configuration (
pdf
) (
ps), Itojun Hagino
- Meeting Summary (
pdf
), S. Deering, B. Hinden
July 1999
The IPng working group held
two working group sessions
on
March 15, 1999
at the Oslo IETF.
The minutes were taken and edited by Allison Mankin.
March 1999
The IPng working group held
two working group sessions
on
March 15, 1999
at the Minneapolis IETF.
The minutes were taken and edited by Bob Hinden.
February 1999
The IPng working group held
working group meeting
on
February 2-4, 1999
in Grenoble France.
The minutes taken by Tony Hain, Steve Deering, Bob Fink and Bob Hinden.
Edited by Bob Hinden.
December 1998
The IPng working group held
working group sessions
on
December 10 & 11, 1998
at the Orlando IETF.
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
August 1998
The IPng working group held
working group sessions
on
August 25 & 27, 1998
at the Chicago
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
March 1998
The IPng working group held
working group sessions
on
March 30, March 31, and April 2, 1998
at the Los Angeles IETF.
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
December 1997
The IPng working group held
working group sessions
on
December 8, 11, and 12, 1997
at the Washington, DC IETF.
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
August 1997
The IPng working group held
working group sessions
on
August 13th and 14th
at the Munich IETF.
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
Some of the presentations given at this meeting are:
April 1997
The IPng working group held an
working group
on
April 10 & 11 1997
at the Memphis IETF.
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
February 1997
The IPng working group held an
interim meeting
on
February 27 & 28 1997
at Palo Alto, CA.
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
December 1996
The IPng working group held
three working group sessions
on
December 9, 12 1996
at the IETF meeting in San Jose, CA.
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
June 1996
The IPng working group held
three working group sessions
on
June 24,25,26, 1996
at the IETF meeting in Montreal, Canada.
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
March 1996
The IPng working group held
three working group sessions
on March 4, 5, and 6, 1996 at the IETF meeting in Los Angles, CA.
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
December 1995
The IPng working group held
two working group sessions
on December 5 and 7, 1995 at the IETF meeting in Dallas, Texas.
The minutes were taken and edited by Robert Hinden.
April 1995
The IPng working group held
three working group sessions
from April 3-5, 1995.
Working group meeting were held on Monday (two
sessions) and Wednesday.
The minutes were taken and edited by Ross Callon.
Februrary 1995
The IPng working group held a
Working Group Meeting
on February 9-10, 1995 at Xerox PARC in Palo Alto, CA. Steve
Deering hosted the meeting.
The minutes were taken and edited by
Frank Solensky.
December 1994
The IPng working group held
five working group sessions and one implementors meeting
from December 4-9, 1994.
Working group meeting were held on Monday (two
sessions), Tuesday, Wednesday, and Friday. The implementors meeting was
held on Sunday prior to the working group meetings.
The minutes were produced based on notes taken by Ross Callon, Frank
Solensky, Dan Harrington, and Robert Hinden.
October 1994
The minutes of the
IPng Implementors Meeting
held at
Digital Equipments Corporation's Cambridge Research Laboratory on
October 10-12, 1994. The meeting was hosted by Jim Bound of Digital
Equipment Corporation. These meeting minutes were created based on
notes taken by Frank Solensky, Ross Callon, and Bob Hinden.
July 1994
An
IPNG Working Group BOF (IPNGWG) was held at the Toronto IETF.
These
minutes
were produced by by Scott Bradner/Harvard University.
This BOF allowed a number of folks to give ten minute presentations on
issues of concern. Over two hundred people
attended
this BOF.
The last SIPP Working Group
meeting
was held at the July IETF in Toronto.
Two working group sessions and one implementors meetings were held. The
first session was on Wednesday and the second session was on Thursday.
The implementors meeting was held on Friday. The minutes for the working
group sessions were taken by Ross Callon. The implementors meeting notes
were taken by Bob Hinden.
Back to IPv6 Home Page