210: Subject: Item #210: Core Errata: better branch descriptions 210: Closed: Item was accepted with changes for publication in the errata. 211: Subject: Item #211: Core Errata: Initial errata list 211: Closed: Item was accepted with changes for publication in the errata. 212: Subject: Item #212: Core Errata: "xxJoin" 212: Closed: supersceded by Proposal #213 and withdrawn by author. 213: Subject: Item #213: Core Errata: "xxSplit and xxJoin" 213: Closed: Withdrawn (see 227) 214: Subject: Item #214: Core Errata: Clarify token substitution of rl@ & rl! 214: Closed: Resubmitted as new proposal 216. 215: Subject: Item #215: Core Errata: Extensible Client Services Package 215: Closed: Accepted with changes as a recommended practice 215: SCOPE: Any OF implementation that has both a client and 215: a device interface. 215: 215: Assign 0x129 to PUSH-PACKAGE, 0x12A to POP-PACKAGE 216: Subject: Item #216: Core Errata: Register-Access words, correction ... 216: Closed: accepted as submitted. To be included in the errata doc. 217: Subject: Item #217: ISA binding: *first draft* 217: Closed: Will carry ISA binding as an agenda item. 218: Subject: Item #218: x86 binding: *first draft* 218: Closed: Will carry x86 binding as a draft. 219: Subject: Item #219: [ Not a proposal - administrative use ] 219: Closed: this item number was used administratively. 220: Subject: Item #220: [ Not a proposal - administrative use ] 220: Closed: this item number was used administratively. 221: Subject: Item #221: PPC Binding: Eliminate "cpu-version" 221: Closed: Withdrawn by Author 222: Subject: Item #222: PPC Binding: Split binding into processor and ... 222: Closed: Accepted with amendments. Vote 8-0-0. New Doc:"PREP Binding..." 223: Subject: Item #223: Create "Device Extensions to IEEE 1275" document 223: Closed: Accepted, Create "common devices" binding. 224: Subject: Item #224: PPC Binding: multiple instances of identical devices 224: Closed: Withdrawn by author. Doc is already fixed 225: Subject: Item #225: Core Errata: Alias expansion bug 225: Closed: Accepted as submitted for core errata. 226: Subject: Item #226: P1275.6: "Split" and "Join" words 226: Closed: Accepted with changes (64 bit extensions supplement) 226: Change text to "active" voice ("Combine ...") 226: CHange split words "will" to "shall" 227: Subject: Item #227: Core Errata: "Split" and "Join" words 227: Closed: Accepted with changes for core errata 227: Change Doc and Version to Core Errata 227: Change join words to "active" voice ("Combine" ...) 227: Change split words "will" to "shall". 228: Subject: Item #228: PPC Binding: Boot Order Change 228: Closed: Withdrawn by author 229: Subject: Item #229: PPC/PReP: Halt-Hibernate 229: Closed: Unanimously rejected. 230: Subject: Item #230: PPC/PReP: Halt-Suspend 230: Closed: accepted with amendments 6-0-4 231: Subject: Item #231: PPC/PReP: Halt-Dump 231: Closed: Unanimously rejected. 232: Subject: Item #232: PPC/PReP: Halt-MCLogout 232: Closed: Unanimously rejected. 233: Subject: Item #233: Core Errata: PAR (IEEE P1275.7) 233: Closed: Accepted. David is directed to submit the PAR 234: Subject: Item #234: Core Errata: Clarify set-symbol-lookup client intfc. 234: Closed: Accepted for inclusion in core errata. 235: Subject: Item #235: PPC Binding: proposal - SCSI device names 235: Closed: Withdrawn by author 236: Subject: Item #236: PCI Binding: Change "reg" prop names 236: Closed: Withdrawn by author's representative. 237: Subject: Item #237: Open Firmware core - Multi-color text 237: Closed: Accepted as ammended as a recommended practice. 237: Some color items moved into #238. 237: Scope: Recommended practice. 238: Subject: Item #238: Open Firmware - Graphics Extension 238: Closed: Accepted as ammended, contingent upon a future proposal as 238: a recommended practice. Include set-colors/get-colors. 238: Future proposal to describe graphics device geometry. 238: Scope: Recommended Practice 239: Subject: Item #239: PPC Binding: Locating Standard Devices 239: Closed: Accepted with amendments. 8-1-1. Amend: All should be aliases. 240: Subject: Item #240: Procedural: Procedure for Binding Meetings 240: Closed: Accepted. Doc to be put on playground 241: Subject: Item #241: PCI Binding: Legacy devices 241: Closed: Accepted as ammended for inclusion in the PCI binding. 241: Include Class Code 0x03.0000 as a VGA device. 241: Ammended Document/Version to PCI Binding/1.4. 241: AI: Ron to run this by Lillian. 242: Subject: Item #242: PCI Binding: assigned-addresses clarification 242: Closed: Accepted with changes (PCI Binding V1.4) 243: Subject: Item #243: PPC binding: reboot command section? 243: Closed: Accepted as amended. Remove lines 37-39 of p.20. 244: Subject: Item #244: PPC binding: reboot command section? 244: Closed: Withdrawn. dup of 243. 245: Subject: Item #245: core document - extended std font ... 245: Closed: Accepted as a strongly recommended practice 245: SCOPE: - FB Support pkg implementations 245: - Any driver that uses DEFAULT-FONT or SET-FONT 245: except as the phrase "default-font set-font" 246: Subject: Item #246: PPC Binding: std default font 246: Closed: Withdrawn by Author. 246: Possibly set ISO Latin 1 as default then change when PE client is 246: recognized. 246: Ron and John K. to look at. 247: Subject: Item #247: 1275 Core Document: "name" props for SCSI devices 247: Closed; Supersceded by Item 251 248: Subject: Item #248: Extension to Core - size method 248: Closed: Accepted; Strongly recommended practice 248: SCOPE: Core and drivers as indicated in the proposal 249: Subject: Item #249: PCI binding: "clock-frequency" bus node property 249: Closed: Accepted as written 250: Subject: Item #250: Procedural: rules for email ballot (Comment NOW!) 250: Pending: Tabled: activate when needed. 251: Subject: Item #251: PCI Binding: Generic names; Recomended Practice) 251: Closed: Accepted as recommended practice 251: SCOPE: PCI bindings and future bindings. 252: Subject: Item #252: PPC Binding: editorial correction name of "root" node 252: Closed: Accepted unanimously as written. 253: Subject: Item #253: PPC Binding: memory usage clarification... 253: Closed: Accepted unanimously as ammended 253: Amend: 253: Change first paragraph to: 253: "Memory that cannot be allocated for general purpose use, for 253: example physical memory on powerpc systems used for interrupt 253: vectors, shall not appear in the "available" property of the 253: memory node. Client Programs that need to use such memory for 253: its architected purpose must not claim that area prior to use". 253: Delete second paragraph. 254: Subject: Item #254: PPC Binding: memory granularity 254: Closed: Accepted unanimously as ammended. 254: Amended as follows: 254: Page 3, lines 28-31 - Remove 4 line note from PPC Binding Draft Document. 254: Insert a new Section 1.5; real mode rules. 254: Move old Section 1.5 to 1.6; Strike open firmware in title. 254: Place sentence in both sections(1.5 & 1.6): 254: "Claim methods shall not allocate more pages than are 254: necessary to satisfy the request". 255: Subject: Item #255: PPC Binding: Virtual mode rules should be revised 255: Accepted: Ammended as follows (June 7' 95): 255: When a client executes set-callback, Open Firmware shall attempt to 255: invoke the "translate" callback. If the translate callback is 255: implemented, Open Firmware shall cease use of address translation 255: hardware, instead using the client callbacks for changes to address 255: translation. 255: 255: The exit service must continue to work after a set-callback that takes 255: over address translation. This implies that Open Firmware takes 255: responsibililty for address translation hardware upon exit and must 255: maintain internal information about translations that it requests of 255: the client. 255: 255: On page 6 of the PowerPC binding, strike line 29. On lines 34 and 35, 255: replace ": shall" with "that take control of the management of 255: address translation hardware and expect to be able to subsequently 255: invoke Open Firmware client services must [provide callbacks ...]" 255: 255: On page 9 of the PowerPC binding, change line 29 to read: 255: 255: The following standard property shall exist within the package to which 255: the "mmu" property of the /chosen package refers: 256: Subject: Item #256: PPC Binding: disk-label package arguments are unclear 256: Accepted: Unanimously. Mitch to finish up algorithm. 257: Subject: Item #257: PPC Binding: BOOTP extensions not specified 257: Closed: Accepted unanimously as amended. 257: Amended as follows: 257: Add to Section 4.2; The obp-tftp package shall 257: not require the server to support any vendor extensions. 258: Subject: Item #258: PPC Binding: timebase-frequency on 601 is unclear 258: Closed: Accepted unanimously as amended. 258: Add a note to section 5.2. The 601 PowerPC does not have a 258: timebase frequency; i.e., the value reported in timebase-frequency 258: property shall be 1 billion which represents the logical rate of 258: the real time clock. 259: Subject: Item #259: PPC Binding: client program formats ... too broadly 259: Closed: Amended and accepted unanimously. 259: Amendments: 259: A new section detailing the ELF header format is added. 260: Subject: Item #260: PPC Binding: load address could be clearer 260: Closed: Accepted unanimously as amended. 260: Amended as follows: 260: Add to section 8.2 "Load Address" the following words: 260: "load-base is a virtual address in virtual mode. 260: load-base is a real address in real mode." 260: Modify sentence: At least 4MB of memory shall be available for loading 260: at that address. 261: Subject: Item #261: PPC Binding: translate client callback return values 261: Closed: Accepted as written 262: Subject: Item #262: PPC Binding: devices 262: Accepted: at June 7,'95 meeting amended as follows 262: 1, 2, and 4 are now in Device Support Extensions; 3 is now in the 262: PReP binding. 262: 262: 1. For PC-101 keyboards, the abort sequence (see install-abort in the 262: IEEE 1275 glossary) shall be Ctrl-Brk. 262: 262: 2. The least significant bit corresponds to the primary (usually the 262: left-most) button of the device. 262: 262: 3.Mitch will take care of the first two subitems in his generic devices 262: document. For the third subitem, substitute the text below. 262: A device node representing the super I/O chip itself need not 262: exist. 262: Change language on p. 8 of PReP binding to "...devices attached 262: to the super I/O chip may be direct children of the bus node 262: representing the bus to which the super I/O chip is attached. 262: 4. Already taken care of (com@...). 263: Subject: Item #263: PPC Binding: typo in binding 263: Closed: Accepted as written 264: Subject: Item #264: PCI Binding: relocatable I/O below 64 KB 264: Closed: Accepted 9-0-2 as written 265: Subject: Item #265: PPC Binding: "regs" property for cpu nodes 265: Withdrawn: At June 7 '95 265: Need a more complete proposal Brian Horn to replace 265 with a 265: detailed 265 proposal. 265: Proposed amendments: 265: Needed SMP Properties. 265: Create regs property such as idle, start, resume 266: Subject: Item #266: RP (Core, PCI): Revisit Generic Names #251 266: Closed: Rejected 1-7-3, reaffirming prev. passed proposal #251 267: Subject: Item #267: PowerPC binding: "hostid" property 267: Accepted: June 7'95, Amended as follows: 267: "system-id" 267: 267: Standard property, encoded as with encode-string, that contains 267: the identification of the computer system. This string shall be 267: unique across all systems and all manufacturers. If the system-id 267: begins with "0", it shall be of the form "0nnnnnnmmmmmm" where nnnnnn 267: is a sequence of 6 uppercase hexadecimal digits representing a 24-bit 267: Organizationally Unique Identifier (OUI) assigned by the IEEE 267: Registration Authority Committee, and mmmmmm is a sequence of 6 267: uppercase hexadecimal digits representing a 24-bit binary number 267: assigned by the manufacturer to assure uniqueness. 267: 267: Note: For systems with built-in ethernet or other IEEE 802-style 267: interfaces, the 6-byte MAC address assigned to that interface meets the 267: requirements and should be used as the system-id. 268: Subject: Item #268: Core recommended practice: "version" property 268: Closed; Passed as ammended. 268: Create a recomended practice for additional properties; 268: "Additional Properties", adding the "version" property, 268: defined here, as the first property included in this RP. 268: SCOPE: All Packages As Needed. 268: Other changes, see text. 269: Subject: Item #269: Core recommended practice: test-method client intfc 269: Closed; Withdrawn (Superseded by #270) 270: Subject: Item #270: Recomended Practice (Core) test-method Ver. 2 270: Closed: Accepted; Passed with minor editorial changes. 271: Subject: Item #271: Open Firmware binding proposal for SMP 271: Closed; Remanded to the author (Luan Nguyen) for amendment. 272: Subject: Item #272: Interposition (Recommended Practice) 272: Closed; Accepted; Passed 7-0-1 as amended. 272: Client interface name changed to instance-to-interposed-path 273: Subject: Item #273: Editorial changes to PCI binding 273: Closed: Accepted; Passed 7-0-1 as ammended. 273: (Editor's discretion) 274: Subject: Item #274: PCI "reg" property clarification 274: Closed; Accepted; Passed as amended. 274: First coda deleted. 274: Second and third coda changed to "Notes" 274: Second coda: "In general" changed to "Typically". 274: Added: Page 16:44-45 Strike 'listed in any child's 274: "reg" property.' 275: Subject: Item #275: PowerPC processor binding, 64-bit properties 275: Closed: Withdrawn by author 276: Subject: Item #276: PowerPC binding V1.3, Open Firmware's use of BATs 276: Closed: Accepted as ammended. 276: Ammend new bullet: 276: A client program shall not directly manipulate any 276: address translation hardware before it either a) ceases to 276: invoke OF client services or b) issues a set-callback to 276: install the "translate" callback. 276: 276: Note: 276: The intended sequence is that a client program will first issue a 276: set-callbak and then take control of address translation hardware. 276: Address translation hardware includes BAT registers, page table, 276: Segment Registers, MSR and the Interrupt vectors relating to 276: translation faults. 277: Subject: Item #277: PowerPC processor binding, 64-bit properties V2 277: Closed: Ammended and Accepted unanimously. 277: Ammended as follows: 277: This property, if present, indicates that the PowerPC microprocessor 277: defined by this CPU node is a 64-bit implementation of the PowerPC 277: Architecture. The absence of this property indicates that the 277: micropresssor defined by this CPU node is a 32 bit implementation 277: of the PowerPC Architecture. 278: Subject: Item #278: PowerPC processor binding, 603 style properties 278: Closed: Accepted as written. 279: Subject: Item #279: ARC console escape sequences 279: Closed; Accepted with changes and merged into the device supplement. 280: Subject: Item #280: Device Support Extensions V0.2, req. for SCSI Devices 280: Closed: Accepted (7-0-0) 281: Subject: Item #281: PReP binding 0.02 halt-address clarification 281: Closed: Accepted unanimously as written. 282: Subject: Item #282: PowerPC default mapping mode 282: Closed: Accepted unanimously as written. 283: Subject: Item #283: Core Errata: Alias expansion buglette 283: Closed: Accepted (7-0-0) 284: Subject: Item #284: PR*P binding: disk label algorithm 284: Closed: Accepted unanimously as written. 285: Subject: Item #285: Core errata: Another minor error in appendix E 285: Closed: Accepted (7-0-0) 286: Subject: Item #286: PCI Supp: Order of reg tuples for non-FCode devices 286: Closed: Remanded to binding committee 286: Binding Committee: Accepted unanimously. 287: Subject: Item #287: PCI Supp: Supply examples to clarify address handling 287: Closed: Remanded to Binding Committee 287: Binding Committee: Passed unanimously 288: Subject: Item #288: Device Supp: new property for wide SCSI 288: Passed as ammended 288: Amendments: 288: New Property "differential". The presence of this property 288: indicates that the device represented by this node supports 288: differential signaling. 288: 288: Insert the following note: 288: "In order to support Wide SCSI the example in Appendix E, section 288: 6.3 of [1] would be ammended as follows." 289: Subject: Item #289: Device Ext: add support for multi-initiator SCSI 289: Closed: Accepted as ammended (change to errata doc) 289: Replace the entire section containing line 52 of page 19 with: 289: : open-hardware ( -- flag ) 289: map 289: 7 to my-id \ NEW *** 289: \ should perform a quick "sanity check" selftest here, 289: \ returning true iff the test succeeds. 289: true 289: ; 289: The change is that the initialization of my-id is done in "open-hardware" 290: Subject: Item #290: PCI Binding: requirements for PCI-PCI bridges 290: Closed: Remanded to binding committee 290: Binding Committee: Passed/Accepted 291: Subject: Item #291: PPC default mode for map not defined 291: Passed/Accepted as ammended 8-1-1 291: If the default mode is -1, a suitable default 291: is chosen: 291: if i/o: W=1, I=1, G=1, PP=10 291: if mem: G=1, PP=10 291: 291: Strike the second paragraph. 291: 291: The third paragraph is noted for a future revision 291: of the errata. (Current errata is closed.) 292: Subject: Item #292: PCI bus-master-capable property 292: Closed: Withdrawn by author (See #293) 293: Subject: Item #293: PCI bus master capable property (revised) 293: Accepted: 11-0-0 294: Subject: Item #294: Dev Ext: Create CS423x Device Support Extension 294: Passed/Accepted as ammended 7-0-2 294: 294: Make the following changes: 294: 294: XCTL -> xctl 294: DMA -> dma 294: underscores -> spaces 294: Change english text in property values to verb first 294: form (i.e. "enable interrupt") 295: Subject: Item #295: Dev Ext: Consistent Properties for Sound Devices 295: Closed: Rejected 295: The committee decided to document a device's capabilities, 295: and not document the current setting of the device. 295: Since the proposal documents 'current settings' rather 295: than capabilities, this was tabled as we anxiously await 295: a revised proposal from the submitter. 296: Subject: Item #296: Dev Ext: "sound" should specify a single data format 296: Passed/Accepted as ammended 9-0-0 296: 296: The editor is directed to use proper normative language. 296: ... passed to _write_ or returned from _read_ 296: Change "signed" to "unsigned". 296: Delete the stanza deleting the properties. 296: Delete the stanza deleting the 'read' method. 296: ... for subsequent reads and/or writes. 296: ... in the definition of "read" and "write" ... 297: Subject: Item #297: Device Support Extensions NVRAM "#bytes" property 297: Passed/Accepted as ammended 297: Add 'size' method with wording to be specified by the editor. 297: (Some manu. specific areas may be excluded from 'size', the 297: area is not available.) 298: Subject: Item #298: DS1385 binding 298: Closed: Accepted as amended. 298: change DS,1385 to ds1385-nvram. 298: Make note about different structure for "reg" property in existing 298: implemenation. 299: Subject: Item #299: PC keyboard device binding 299: Closed: Accepted. Jordan to draft PC Keyboard Binding. 300: Subject: Item #300: Device Ext: max-scsi-targets property 300: Closed: Withdrawn by author 301: Subject: Item #301: 8042 device binding 301: Closed: Accepted as amended 301: Amendments: 301: Delete section titled "Additional Requirements" 301: 8042 device binding to be created. 302: Subject: Item #302: PReP floppy and ide device types are inappropriate 302: Closed: Accepted as amended. 302: Amendments: 302: Change floppy to fdc node name and device type. 302: Clarification: Alias floppy refers to primary floppy drive 303: Subject: Item #303: PCI Bus Binding: Create reserved word in the PCI node 303: Passed as ammenended 9-0-1 303: Add an FCode driver example note to the PCI binding 303: (to be supplied by Mitch). 304: Subject: Item #304: Device binding drafts for a variety of PC devices 304: Closed: Withdrawn by author (See #305) 305: Subject: Item #305: Device binding drafts for a variety ... (v1.1) 305: Closed: Accepted as amended: 305: Proposal separated into three sections: 305: 305A - Template for device bindings. Accepted 305: 305B - Serial Device Binding proposal. Accepted 305: Need to add generic parameters in device extension document 305: for the open method for serial port. Make into draft binding 305: document. 305: 305C - Closed. Remainder of text to be resubmitted as separate 305: proposals. 306: Subject: Item #306: PowerPC processor binding update 306: Closed: Accepted as amended. 306: This proposal creates PowerPC Binding Version 1.9 Draft 307: Subject: Item #307: PPC -- Real Base, Load Base comments 307: Closed: Withdrawn 308: Subject: Item #308: PCI Binding: firware should set cache line size 308: Closed/Accepted with ammendments (10-0-0) 308: Add wording to read back the cache-line-size register, 308: if the value is zero, don't create the property. 309: Subject: Item #309: OFWG Minutes 01/16/95 309: Closed administratively (minutes have been posted) 310: Subject: Item #310: PCI Binding: secondary latency timer 310: Accepted as ammended: 8-0-0 310: Leave it up to the implementation (and describe in a footnote) 310: referring to section 3.5 in 2.1 PCI Spec, as to the trade-offs 310: in programming the primary latency timer. (See also section 310: 5.5.18 in the PCI Bridge Spec 1.0) 311: Subject: Item #311: PCI: Item#303: Ammendment 311: Closed/Accepted: editor's discretion on wording update (10-0-0) 312: Subject: Item #312: PPC: Add load-base to .note section 312: Closed: Accepted 312: This proposal refers to material which was removed from the 312: PPC processor binding, to be put in the platform bindings. 312: Moved to freeze PReP, add to CHRP only. For PReP; voted to reject 8-0-0. 312: Add to CHRP binding. 313.0 Closed:rejected 313.1 The PowerPC Architecture will clarify that only 3 pages will be 313.2 reserved for implementation specific area. 313: Subject: Item #313: PPC: #trap-pages property 314: Subject: Item #314: PCI: get-inherited-property bug in Apple OF 314: Closed/Accepted as written, 10-0-0 315: Subject: Item #315: PPC: binding update from CHRP 315: Closed/Withdrawn by author; Superceded by #317 316: Subject: Item #316: PPC: Binding committee meeting minutes 1/17/96 316: Closed/Withdrawn (See #325) 317: Subject: Item #317: PPC: Processor binding update from CHRP 317:0 Closed: Accepted with amendments 317:1 Amendments: 317:2 Page 10, line 3: Replace entire paragraph: 317:3 "If the client program has specific requirements for physical 317:4 memory or address space usage, it may establish requirements 317:5 for OF's physical and/or virtual address space usage by means 317:6 of its program header. When OF loads the client program, it 317:7 inspects the program header, and if its current usage of 317:8 physical memory or virtual address space conflicts with that 317:9 specified in the program header, OF shall set the real-base, 317:0 real-size, virt-base, and virt-size to the configuration 317:1 variables as specified in the header and restart itself. 317:2 real-base, virt-base, real-size and virt-size may be specified 317:3 as -1, in which case the firmware is permitted to choose 317:4 appropriate values for the variables specified as -1." 317:5 Page 10, line 7: Replace paragraph beginning at line 7: 317:6 "If the values of the real-size and/or virt-size config vars do 317:7 not provide sufficient memory and/or virtual address space for 317:8 the firmware's own use, then the firmware shall not attempt to 317:9 load a client program and the condition should be reported to 317:0 the user. The possibility of not being able to comply with 317:1 limitiations on firmware's size should be tested as the 317:2 firmware is coming up in order to handle the possibility that 317:3 a user established an unworkable limitation on the size." 317:4 317:5 Add "Clients can minimize this exposure by setting the size to 317:6 -1 and allowing Open Firmware to choose the size." 317:7 Page 11, lines 24-27: Client programs are not required to assume 317:8 responsibility for physical memory management. Put at beginning 317:9 of paragraph. State in both pos and neg context. 317:0 Page 18: split Table 1 into sections: real-mode and virt-mode; 317:1 change "preserved by client interface" to "client interface shall 317:2 preserve"; add definition for preserved - same value when returing; 317:3 indicate that the msr, segment registers & sprg registers shall 317:4 not be modified by the client interface in virtual mode; indicate 317:5 that the msr, segment registers & sprg registers shall be preserved 317:6 by the client interface in real mode; remove '%' signs in this 317:7 section. 317:8 Page 19, Table 2: Change "Others" to "Other user mode registers". 317:9 Page 19, lines 8-15: replace the 3rd and 4th sentences with the def. 317:0 of load-base. Add the proposed sentence to the end of the paragraph. 317:1 Page 20, line 40: After the first sentence add: 317:2 "The I cache shall be consistent with the D cache for all 317:3 memory areas occupied by the client program." 317:4 Page 20, after line 43: Add: 317:5 "All processors in a SMP system shall have the same 317:6 consistent view of all memory areas (for data references). 317:7 No more than one processor shall have a modified copy of 317:8 the same data area in its cache when the client program 317:9 is called. 317:0 Note: If firmware makes cachable M=0 data references from 317:1 different processors on a SMP system, it may have to 317:2 perform additional cache management to meet this 317:3 requirement." 317:4 Page 22, line 30: Segment Register's sentence, don't add. 317:5 Page 22, lines 52-54: Move lines to behind line 12. 317:6 317:7 Moved to make changes as amended above and update binding to 317:8 Revision 1.10 DRAFT. 318: Subject: Item #318: Administrivia: OFWG Agenda for March Meeting 318: Closed/Withdrawn (See #319) 319: Subject: Item #319: Administrivia: New OFWG Agenda for March Meeting 319: Closed/Administratively (agenda posted) 320: Subject: Item #320: ISA Binding: Define new physical address format ... 320: Closed; Withdrawn by author 321: Subject: Item #321: new recommended practice: Interrupt Mapping 321: Closed: See #355 322: Subject: Item #322: recommended practice: Forth source & FCode image ... 322: Closed: Withdrawn by author 322: line-ending definition and wording needs work 323: Subject: Item #323: change to *output* definition 323: Closed; (323.a Accepted; 323.b Withdrawn) 323: Proposal split into two parts: 323: a) Update PCI Binding 4.2.1 for non-relocatable PCI devices: 323: Additional requirement on the close method of child devices: 323: close( ) 323: 323: Disable fixed-address response by closing Memory space and I/O 323: space and BusMaster enable bits in the command register. 323: Use similar wording on p17, line 12. 323: 323: 323.a is closed and has been incorporated into PCI 1.7d 323: 323: b) Create recommended practice for output devices (e.g. VGA) 323: Ron and Mitch to work this offline 323: 323: 323.b is withdrawn (Jordan to propose wording in a future proposal) 324: Subject: Item #324: New Draft Recommended Practice: 'Generic Names' 324: Closed; See #336 324: 324: names assigned to PCI Class codes; added to 324: list on p.4 as appropriate. Add "authorization" clause. 324: Editor to generate 1.1 "unapproved draft." 325: Subject: Item #325: Amended PowerPC Committee meeting minutes 1/17/96 325: Closed: Accepted with amendment 325: Amendment: Add Bob Coffin to attendee's list 326: Subject: Item #326: PCI Binding: Clarify address space allocation ... 326: Closed; Accepted as ammended 9-0-1 326: The proposal is replaced with the following: 326: 326: Replace p17, line 38, sentence beginning with "For each base ..." 326: with the following: 326: 326: For each child node, create an "assigned-addresses" property 326: with an entry for each base address register (or register pair) 326: for which an address was assigned. 327: Subject: Item #327: PCI Binding: "latency-timer" property 327: Accepted as ammended: 8-0-0 327: Leave it up to the implementation (and describe in a footnote) 327: referring to section 3.5 in 2.1 PCI Spec, as to the trade-offs 327: in programming the primary latency timer. 328: Subject: Item #328: SCSI-3 Binding: Create binding document 328: Closed: Withdrawn (See #333) 329: Subject: Item #329: OFWG Minutes 03/06/96 329: Closed, Minutes Approved 330: Subject: Item #330: PPC: L2 cache property proposal 330: Closed; Remanded to Subcommittee 330: Subcommittee Status: Closed/Rejected 330: rejected for lack of rationale (AI S9) 331: Subject: Item #331: Generic name for the keyboard/mouse controller 331: Closed; Withdrawn by author 332: Subject: Item #332: OFWG Minutes 03/06/96 (second day) 332: Closed; Remanded 332: Subcommittee: Minutes approved 333: Subject: Item #333: SCSI-3 Binding: Create binding document 333: Closed; Withdrawn (See #352) 334: Subject: Item #334: Device Support Extensions: Draft Version 0.6 334: Closed: Withdrawn 335: Subject: Item #335: ISA/EISA/ISA-PnP Draft version 0.2 335: Closed: New Draft has been posted 336: Subject: Item #336: Generic Names Rec. Practice, Draft 1.1 336: Closed; Supersceded by GDN 1.2 336: Jordan is preparing a proposal to move PCI specific stuff 336: to the PCI binding. (Table #1), Change Section 6 to informative. 336: Change 'processor' to 'cpu'. 337: Subject: Item #337: Dev Sup Ext 0.6: "mouse" get-event clarification 337: Closed; Accepted as ammended 9-0-0 337: Ammended as follows: 337: Change i.e. "'x' values increase when moving to the 'right' 337: and 'y' values increase whem moving 'down'. 338: Subject: Item #338: Dev Sup Ext: scancode methods 338: Closed, Accepted as ammended 10-0-1 338: Ammended as follows: 338: Replace the text of the proposal with the following: 338: Delete all references to get-scancode, scancode->char, 338: set-language. 339: Subject: Item #339: Administrivia: OFWG Agenda for April/May Meeting 339: Closed; Agenda approved 340: Subject: Item #340: PCI Binding: add "latency-timer" property 340: Closed; Withdrawn (See #327) 341: Subject: Item #341: Device Support Extensions: Clarify Scope 341: Closed; Withdrawn (See #342) 342: Subject: Item #342: Device Support Extensions: Clarify Scope 342: Closed; Remanded: Subcommittee: Accepted as ammended 342: Ammendment: 342: Convert DSE to Recommended Practice Document with a 'purpose' section. 342: Change SCSI to SCSI-2 in the document. 343: Subject: Item #343: What does "compatible" mean? 343: Closed; Accepted as ammended 8-0-0 343: Ammendments: 343: The last sentence of 3.1 and the term "[ their ] defined semantics 343: needs clarification. Section 5 needs to be rewritten. 343: The ammended text should be folded into a rewritten and 343: and renamed "Generic Names" recommended practice document. 343: Jordan and Bob are directed to create such a document and submit 343: it for committee approval. 344: Subject: Item #344: PC keyboard/mouse controller binding 344: Closed; Remanded 344: Subcommittee Status: Closed/Withdrawn, Author has AI to rev document 344: 344: Ammendments: 344: - Change textual representation (7.2.1) from "main" to "0" and 344: from "aux" to "1". 344: - call out all of the methods and properties (incl reg) 344: - "slot-names" should be consistent with the PCI binding (bit mask) 345: Subject: Item #345: CS4231 Device Binding 345: Closed; Remanded (Subcommittee Status: Accepted with ammendments, 345: The editor is directed to produce a new version with the ammendments.) 345: 345: Ammendments: 345: 345: - xctl0/1 typos -- control line 0, bit # 345: - Confirm devices that 423x applies to 346: Subject: Item #346: Dallas Semiconductor 1385 Device Binding 346: Closed; Remanded (Accepted by subcommittee) 346: Editor is directed to produce an accepted std version of this document. 347: Subject: Item #347: PC Keyboard Device Binding 347: Closed; Remanded (Subcommittee: Withdrawn) 347: The editor is directed to produce a new version including the following 347: ammendments to the document: 347: 347: - Contents of 7.2.1 go away 347: - Tag the layout as optional (if the firmware knows) 347: - Section 9 use "shall" as appropriate 347: - Section 9.3 -- delete or reword since the implication is that 347: Open Firmware must figure out what to do with respect to the 347: indicator state when enter is pressed. 348: Subject: Item #348: PC Serial Port Device Binding 348: Closed; Remanded (Accepted with ammendments) 348: Ammendments: 348: - Add reference to pnpPNP,501 348: - Clock frequency should be in hertz 348: 348: - Pick up methods from CHRP serial device binding (or move to DSE) 348: The editor is directed to produce an approved version 1.0 with these 348: ammendments with an AI to suggest 'name' convention to recognize 348: SuperIO chips. 349: Subject: Item #349: PCI Bindings: clarify use of probe-pci 349: Closed; Rejected 349: The PCI binding was separately ammended to do some of this. 350: Subject: Item #350: DSE: "sound" properties ... 350: Closed; accepted as amended and incorporated in the DSE 350: Ammendments: 350: - Delete sentence in 6.2 starting "The following prop..." 350: - In 6.2 except for device_type, delete "Standard" in front 350: of "property name" 350: - Clarify what the interpertation is for "#x-channels" (each integer 350: specifies the possible number of channels supported in a specific mode 350: of the device. E.g, a 1 indicates monophonic, 2 indicates stereophonic) 350: - "sample-frame-size" needs clarification (bits or bytes) 351: Subject: Item #351: OBP-TFTP Recomended Practice Draft 0.5 351: Closed; Withdrawn 351: Suggested Changes published in #356 (minutes of Apr 30 - May 1 meeting) 351: Author to resubmit a new draft with changes discussed at the meeting. 352: Subject: Item #352: SCSI-3 Binding: Create initial binding 352: Closed; Withdrawn 352: The sense of the committee is that SBP can be handled with 352: a proposal to ammend the existing SCSI-2 'binding', and that 352: FC, FC-AL and 1394 should be handled as cases in their native 352: buses with bindings for those buses. The author is encouraged 352: to resubmit a proposal for SCSI-2 mods to support the extended 352: addressing capabilities of SBP. 353: Subject: Item #353: PCI Binding ROM Image format 353: Closed; Accepted as ammended 11-0-0 353: Ammended as follows: 353: Replace the proposal with the following text: 353: Strike line 9. Line 10: Change 38h to 1Ah 354: Subject: Item #354: PPC/PReP: Halt-address is dead; long live RTAS 354: Closed; Remanded to the binding committee 354: Binding Committee Status: Accepted 9-0-0 354: Jordan to make updates and publish a revised binding. 355: Subject: Item #355: Interrupt Mapping RP, Unapproved Draft 0.6 355: Closed; Rejected 355: New proposal to be submitted by the author. 355: Some questions w.r.t. "interrupts" versus "masking". 356: Subject: Item #356: Administrivia: OFWG Minutes for April/May Meeting 356: Closed; Minutes Approved 357: Subject: Item #357: CHRP: Proposal for CHRP binding Availability 357: Closed Administratively 358: Subject: Item #358: Generic Names RP: Don't reserve names 358: Closed; Accepted 359: Subject: Item #359: Proposal for CHRP Device Bindings 359: Closed Administratively 359: See minutes for changes suggested to 8042 and Serial device bindings 360: Subject: Item #360: CHRP: Genericize PIC controller name 360: Closed; Withdrawn by author. (included in latest revision) 361: Subject: Item #361: CHRP PIC dev: add "reserved-interrupts" property 361: Closed; Withdrawn by author, updated binding to be submitted 362: Subject: Item #362: ISA: ISA-PnP Unit Address Format 362: Closed; Remanded (Accepted by subcommittee with ammendments) 362: - Reject change of address format, instead delete 10:39 - 11:14. 362: Create a 'pnp-id' property, value 2 endoded as with encode-string 362: as shown on 11:27-41 (line 32 should be ascii and the VVV should 362: be "upper case ASCII" instead of 5-bit. 362: - Propose 9:25, 9:28 , lower case m before all "n"s, line 25 "i" in 362: brackets (add text to explain why optional). "i" is assumed if string 362: does not begin with i,t,v or m. (Greg to work with Bob for wording). 362: - Change "isa" to "pnp" for the "name" property. Add usual wording for 362: name and compatible properties. Jordan and Bob to deal with wording. 362: (name to use master pnp) 362: - Change "Sun MicroSystems" to "Sun Microsystems Inc." on page 3 363: Subject: Item #363: PPC: PPC Update PowerPC processor binding V 1.10 363: Closed; Remanded (Accepted) 364: Subject: Item #364: TFTP Boot Extensions RP: Draft 0.6 posted 364: Closed; Withdrawn 364: The author is directed to submit a new version with several changes 364: as noted in the minutes of the June 26, 1996 OFWG meeting 365: Subject: Item #365: Intr. Map RP: Draft 0.8 posted 365: Closed; Withdrawn 365: The author is directed to submit a new version of the proposal 365: with the changes discussed at the June 26, 1996 OFWG meeting. 366: Subject: Item #366: PCI: Draft 1.75 posted 366: Closed; Accepted with ammendments 366: Accepted with several ammendments documented in the June 26, 1996 366: meeting minutes. 366: 366: The editor is directed to create an approved version of the PCI 366: with the ammendments documented in the minutes. 367: Subject: Item #367: PCI Binding 1.75 ranges property update 367: Closed; Accepted with ammendment: 367: 367: P15:10 add the following sentence: 367: "If no addresses are mapped through the bridge, the 'ranges' 367: property shall be absent". 368: Subject: Item #368: Administrivia: OFWG Agenda for June Meeting 368: Closed; Agenda Approved 369: Subject: Item #369: PCI Binding: available property for bus nodes 369: Closed; Accepted 11-0-0 370: Subject: Item #370: 64-bit Extensions: FCode32 Compatibility 370: Closed; Accepted with ammendments: 370: Section 6 needs a normative statement to make the section 370: a requirement. 370: Add 'mask' to the list (quadlet pointer) 371: Subject: Item #371: Admin: OFWG Minutes for June Meeting 371: Closed; Withdrawn -- Ammended and resubmitted as #372 and #373 372: Subject: Item #372: Admin: OFWG Minutes for June Meeting (revised) 372: Closed; Withdrawn -- Ammended and resubmitted as #373 373: Subject: Item #373: Admin: OFWG Minutes for June Meeting (revised) 373: Closed; Withdrawn -- Ammended and resubmitted as #374 374: Subject: Item #374: Admin: OFWG Minutes for June Meeting (revised) 374: Closed; Minutes Approved. 375: Subject: Item #375: SPI Binding: Draft 1 375: Approved as ammended, moved to have author produce draft document. 375: add in Section 3.1.1, "name" should be "scsi" if using generic names. 376: Subject: Item #376: CHRP system binding: chosen nvram 376: Closed; Approved as ammended: 376: Ammendments: 376: Add to the note in DSE that the size returned by the SIZE 376: method will be the platform defined nvram size. OF/OS 376: should only address nvram from 0 up to this size-1. 377: Subject: Item #377: CHRP system binding: internal (dummy) nodes 377: Closed; Approved as ammended: 377: - change to "internal" to "reserved" 377: - add device_type of reserved 378: Subject: Item #378: TFTP Booting Extensions RP Property Values 378: Closed; Accepted as ammended: 378: - delete "15pin" wherever it occurs 378: - update fddi connectors 379: Subject: Item #379: TFTP Booting Extensions RP Open Argument Values 379: Closed; Approved as ammended: 379: - change target document to DSE (add Network section) 379: - move section 5 from TFTP to DSE 380: Subject: Item #380: PCI: Include pci class code string in 'compatible' 380: Closed; Accepted as ammended 11-0-0 380: - form of name shall be "pciclass,NNNNNN" 380: - NNNNNN shall be lower case hex including leading zeroes 380: - delete the last sentence of the paragraph 381: Subject: Item #381: PC keyboard/mouse controller binding 381: Closed; Approved (Editor is directed to produce 1.0 approved vers.) 382: Subject: Item #382: PC keyboard device binding v0.3 382: Closed; Accepted with ammendments: 382: - fix [3] "???" [ Correct reference 3 ] 382: - fix "??" at XT keyboard in section 4 [ Correct reference to [3] ] 382: - add references for ANSI/ISO 382: - mention "Windows 95" keyboard in section 5 382: - section 6 -- "none" for now 382: - end of 7.2.1 delete "or empty" 382: - 7.2.2 keyboard indicators should match 382: - copy abort sequence from DSE to this doc. 382: - specify open arguments 382: - Move list of layouts in 7.1.2 to an appendix/registry. 383: Subject: Item #383: clarifications on MEMORY-TEST-SUITE and MASK 383: Closed; Withdrawn by author (Author to submit a clarification) 383: Comments: 383: memory-test-suite may not work for PCI memory on a big endian 383: platform. Need statements somewhere about situations in which 383: memory-test-suite is likely not to work and guidance for making 383: an endian independent memory-test-suite. 383: AI for WMB/DMK to take a to look at 64-bit MASK 384: Subject: Item #384: PC Serial Port Device Binding 384: Closed; Accepted with ammendments (10-0-1) 384: - move 7.2 contents to DSE 384: - strike bracketed note at 9.1 384: - 9.1 last para -- change "devices which are" to "devices that are" 384: - change "pnp500's" to "may" instead of "should" 385: Subject: Item #385: OFWG Meeting (08/13-14/96) Proposed Agenda 385: Closed; Withdrawn (Duplicate of #386) 386: Subject: Item #386: Administrivia: Agenda for August meeting 386: Closed; Agenda Approved 387: Subject: Item #387: Administrative: OFWG Minutes for August Meeting 387: Closed/Accepted 388: Subject: Item #388: Request email balloting of Item #250 388: Closed; Withdrawn by author 389: Subject: Item #389: Core: Stack diagram error in endcase and b(endcase) 389: Closed; Accepted 390: Subject: Item #390: PPC: reserved area size increase 390: Closed, Accepted as ammended 390: Remove the memory reservation and add a note 390: that there used to be a memory reservation. 391: Subject: Item #391: DSE: Clarify Arguments to network Devices 391: Closed; Accepted as ammended: 391: Page 13; After line 49 add 391: The following arguments shown above must come first. 391: The commas are only present if there is a following parameter. 392: Subject: Item #392: Administrative: Agenda for October OFWG Meeting 392: Closed; Accepted with right of revision. 393: Subject: Item #393: Administrative: OFWG Minutes for October Meeting 393: Closed; Accepted 394: Subject: Item #394: ISA bus: Typo in binding "interrupts" 394: Closed; Withdrawn 394: The typo was corrected in earlier version of the document. 395: Subject: Item #395: PCI bus: Typo in binding - ss coding for ... 395: Closed; Accepted 396: Subject: Item #396: Improve max-transfer example. 396: Closed; Accepted 396: Link this item to the errata section of the web site. 397: Subject: Item #397: DSE: 'auto' string in network device properties 397: Closed; Accepted as ammended 397: accepted as ammended; change wording for the "chosen-network-type" 397: property to reflect what result value for 'speed' and 'duplex mode' 397: was selected or negotiated for the adapter ('auto' string would not 397: be in the result value of "chosen-network-type" property). Tech- 397: nical editor to provide wording to include in new Device Support 397: Extension-RP Version. 398: Subject: Item #398: OBP-TFTP: additional 'ping' parameters 398: Closed; Accepted as ammended 398: put brackets around 'client-ip' for ping 398: command definition and include [bootp] in the device arguments 398: definition. Technical editor to include in new version of 398: TFTP Booting Extension-RP. 399: Subject: Item #399: PCI Bus: map-in/out clarification. 399: Closed; Rejected 399: rejected; covered in definition of 'map-in', PCI binding (author 399: agreed that item was already covered in PCI binding) 400: Subject: Item #400: PCI Bus v2.0: Typo in 4.1.2.1 400: Closed; Accepted 401: Subject: Item #401: Agenda for OFWG Salt Lake City Meeting - January 401: Closed; Accepted 402: Subject: Item #402: Interrupt Mapping 0.9 402: Closed; Accepted as ammended 402: accepted as ammended; Technical editor to update code that allows 402: "#address-cells" to have a value of zero to indicate not to use 402: unit-address for a case where a device can directly point to an 402: interrupt controller via the "interrupt-parent" property and to 402: also update an example. 403: Subject: Item #403: Re: Item #402: Interrupt Mapping 0.9 403: Closed; Withdrawn by author (wasn't intended as a proposal) 404: Subject: Item #404: SCSI Annex retry improvements 404: Closed; Accepted 405: Subject: Item #405: pci v2.0: Add 'vendor-id' to 'compatible' 405: Closed; Accepted 406: Subject: Item #406: Minutes for OFWG January 1997 Meeting 406: Closed; Accepted with ammendments 406: A. Correction of the spelling of Tracy Hallock's name 406: B. Notation that Mitch Bradley suffered a case of frost bite. 406: C. Notation that the April 15th Austin, TX meeting was 406: subsequently cancelled. 407: Subject: Item #407: VME Bus: VME Bus binding d9 407: Closed; Approved with a contigency 407: Approved contingent upon the author modifying the "boilerplate" from 407: IEEE Standard to Open Firmware Recommended Practice. 408: Subject: Item #408: Proposed Bus Binding for IEEE 1394/firewire 408: Closed; Withdrawn 408: The working group made numerous suggestions to the author. The 408: proposal was subsequently withdrawn and the author will re-submit a 408: formal Binding draft document incorporating the working group's feed 408: back 409: Subject: Item #409: Set-Resolution method for graphics drivers 409: Closed; Rejected 409: The sense of the working group was that this proposal was insufficient 409: to address the problems in all but the most degenerate cases. 409: Mitch Bradley proposed the addition of a property to reflect all display 409: modes supported by the adapter along with those supported by the 409: rendering firmware plus methods for reporting the current mode and 409: switching modes. 410: Subject: Item #410: Proposal for "dma-ranges" property 410: Closed; Accepted with the following clarification 410: A. This practice defines a standard property which, if it exists, 410: defines a fixed translation between the DMA space and system 410: address space. 410: B. The degenerate case of the "dam-ranges" property in the root 410: node reflects a fixed translation performed by the platform's 410: core logic. 410: C. While the "dma-ranges" property is, in general, optional, 410: it may become a required component of certain bindings. 411: Subject: Item #411: Mac HFS support for CHRP 411: Closed; Withdrawn 411: The working group made numerous suggestions to the author. The author 411: subsequently withdrew the proposal and will work electronically with 411: members of the CHRP sub group (specifically Richard Arndt and Bruce 411: Rosenkrantz) to re-submit the proposal 412: Subject: Item #412: RE: Item #411: Mac HFS support for CHRP 412: Closed administratively (not a proposal) 413: Subject: Item #413: Agenda: July 15/16, 1997 Meeting @ Firmworks 413: Closed; Accepted with right of revision. 414: Subject: Item #414: PCI-IDE device binding (overview) 414: Closed; Withdrawn 414: See minutes 15-Jul-1997 (Proposal #422) for details of 414: OFWG suggestions and recomendations. The working group 414: authorized the author to produce a formal draft binding 414: based upon this proposal as augmented by the discussion. 415: Subject: Item #415: Re: Item #414: PCI-IDE device binding (overview) 415: Closed; Not a proposal 416: Subject: Item #416: administrative test -- ignore 416: Closed administratively, not a proposal 417: Subject: Item #417: administrative test 417: Closed administratively, not a proposal 418: Subject: Item #418: sorry, still testing 418: Closed administratively, not a proposal 419: Subject: Item #419: CHRP: Backslash in Bootinfo Entities ... 419: Closed; Approved without objection 420: Subject: Item #420: PCI: Correction to dma-map-in stack diagram 420: Closed; Approved without objection 421: Subject: Item #421: Re: Item #411: Mac HFS support for CHRP 421: Closed administratively; Not a proposal 422: Subject: Item #422: Minutes 15 Jul 97 OFWG 422: Closed; Accepted (typos noted) 423: Subject: Item #423: OBP-TFTP RP: /chosen/bootreply-packet ... 423: Closed; Supersceded by #424 and withdrawn by author 424: Subject: Item #424: OBP-TFTP RP: /chosen/bootreply-packet ... 424: Closed; Accepted 425: Subject: Item #425: Core Errata: fix show-lun method 425: Closed; Accepted 426: Subject: Item #426: Revised Bus Binding for IEEE 1394/firewire 426: Closed; See #428 427: Subject: Item #427: USB Bus Binding, Draft 0.1 427: Closed; 427: Several Changes recommended. See minutes in #429 428: Subject: Item #428: Revised Bus Binding for IEEE 1394/firewire 428: Closed 428: Several Changes Recommended; See minutes #429 429: Subject: Item #429: Minutes 11 Nov 97 OFWG 429: Closed; Accepted 429: Reassign second AI #41 to #42 David Kahn 430: Subject: Item #430: PCI Binding: Expand PCI compatible/name ... 430: Closed; Accepted with Ammendments 430: Strike lines 113 - 118 of the proposal (changes to para. "name") 430: Add the word "Note:" to line 153 of the proposal to indicate that 430: the paragraph ("Entry (3) is supplied ...") is informative. 431: Subject: Item #431: CoderLink web site open ! 431: Closed; Not a proposal 432: Subject: Item #432: USB Binding Draft 0.2 432: Approved. 433: Subject: Item #433: ARM Processor Binding, draft 0.3 433: Closed; Accepted as ammended 433: Page 12:26-42 typo call-static-method instead of call-method 433: Strike sections 7.1.3 and 7.2 and 7.2.1 (page 18:29-39) 433: Strike 'up', 'tos', 'rp' and 'ip' (page 18:4-14) 434: Subject: Item #434: Digital Network Appliance Platform Binding 0.2d 434: Closed; Approved as ammended 434: Page 2 Section 3 Line 12; Change "Appliance" to "Architecture" 434: Page 3:40-46 Delete 0x20's 434: Page 4 Note on line 3 Typos 434: Page 6:35 ISA RTC change to Open Prom 435: Subject: Item #435: Revised Bus Binding for IEEE 1394/firewire 435: Closed; Accepted as ammended 435: Add a 'wait' method for checking for operation completion and 435: handling non-dma devices. 435: Add normative statement for required Control Child nodes 435: Line 412: strike "will" 435: Globally change "1394" to "IEEE 1394". 436: Subject: Item #436: FC/AL SCSI FCP proposed binding 436: Closed; Remanded to author to make official version 436: Remove "diagnose" method (lines 303-311) 436: Change "lid-to-wwn" to "loopid-to-wwn" ... 436: (error-code | wwn.lo wwn.hi 0) optional 437: Subject: Item #437: Minutes 17 March 1998 OFWG Meeting 437: Closed; Approved 438: Subject: Item #438: Wednesday 438: Closed Administratively; Not a proposal 439: Subject: Item #439: ARM Processor Binding: Correction to claim-phys ... 439: Closed; Accepted 440: Subject: Item #440: clarify SET-CALLBACK unset value 440: Closed; Accepted .. Post to "additional core errata" 441: Subject: Item #441: ++Bull*sEye-*Targeting*Software* 441: Closed Administratively; Not a proposal 442: Subject: Item #442: testing moved proposal daemon 442: Closed; Not a proposal 443: Subject: Item #443: OFWG Agenda 01 Sept 1998 443: Closed; Accepted 444: Subject: Item #444: 444: Closed; Not a proposal 445: Subject: Item #445: 445: Closed; Not a proposal 446: Subject: Item #446: 446: Closed; Not a proposal 447: Subject: Item #447: Minutes -- 1 Sep 1998 OFWG Meeting 447: Closed; Accepted as submitted 448: Subject: Item #448: The definition of ABORT" function is unclear 448: Closed; Accepted as ammended 448: Change the text of the proposal to: 448: 448: The following statement reflects the intention of the committee: 448: 448: The version of ABORT" defined by the ANS Forth EXCEPTION wordset 448: applies. 449: Subject: Item #449: The definition of ABORT function is unclear 449: Closed; Accepted as ammended 449: Replace the proposal with the following text: 449: 449: The committee notes that the one-line description of ABORT 449: is misleading, however, the long version is correct. 450: Subject: Item #450: (Not a proposal .. text and subject deleted) 450: Closed: Not a proposal 451: Subject: Item #451: (Advertisement .. text and subject deleted) 451: Closed: Not a proposal 452: Subject: Item #452: (Advertisement .. text and subject deleted) 452: Closed: Not a proposal 453: Subject: Item #453: (Advertisement .. text and subject deleted) 453: Closed: Not a proposal 454: Subject: Item #454: (Advertisement .. text and subject deleted) 454: Closed: Not a proposal 455: Subject: Item #455: (Advertisement .. text and subject deleted) 455: Closed: Not a proposal 456: Subject: Item #456: (Advertisement .. text and subject deleted) 456: Closed: Not a proposal 457: Subject: Item #457: USB Binding: support for recursive probing 457: Closed; Rejected 458: Subject: Item #458: 64-bit Extension Wordset is incomplete 458: Closed; Withdrawn 459: Subject: Item #459: PCI Binding: More that 256 buses 459: Closed; Withdrawn by author 460: Subject: Item #460: Agenda OFWG meeting 9 March 99 460: Closed; Accepted as agenda item 461: Subject: Item #461: Minutes OFWG meeting 9 March 99 461: Closed; Withdrawn ... Replaced by #462 462: Subject: Item #462: Minutes OFWG meeting 9 March 99 462: New: not yet discussed 463: Subject: Item #463: [ Not a proposal; Subject Deleted ] 463: Closed: Not a proposal 464: Subject: Item #464: [ Not a proposal; Subject Deleted ] 464: Closed: Not a proposal 465: Subject: Item #465: [ Not a proposal; Subject Deleted ] 465: Closed; Not a proposal 466: Subject: Item #466: [ Not a proposal; Subject Deleted ] 466: Closed; Not a proposal 467: Subject: Item #467: (Not a proposal) 467: Closed: Not a proposal 468: Subject: Item #468: (Not a proposal) 468: Closed: Not a proposal 469: Subject: Item #469: (Not a proposal) 469: Closed: Not a proposal. 470: Subject: Item #470: (Not a proposal) 470: Closed: Not a proposal 471: Subject: Item #471: (Not a proposal) 471: Closed: Not a proposal 472: Subject: Item #472: (Not a proposal) 472: Closed: Not a proposal 473: Subject: Item #473: (Not a proposal) 473: Closed: Not a proposal 474: Subject: Item #474: USB Binding: Revise the Name Tables 474: New: not yet discussed 475: Subject: Item #475: (Not a proposal) 475: Closed: Not a proposal 476: Subject: Item #476: (Not a proposal) 476: Closed: Not a proposal 477: Subject: Item #477: (Not a proposal) 477: Closet; Not a proposal 478: Subject: Item #478: (Not a proposal) 478: Closed; Not a proposal 479: Subject: Item #479: (Not a proposal) 479: Closed: Junk mail 480: Subject: Item #480: (Not a proposal) 480: Closed: Junk mail 481: Subject: Item #481: (Not a proposal) 481: Closed: Junk 482: Subject: Item #482: (Not a proposal) 482: Closed: Junk 483: Subject: Item #483: (Not a proposal) 483: Closed: Junk 484: Subject: Item #484: (Not a proposal) 484: Closed: Junk 485: Subject: Item #485: (Not a proposal) 485: Closed: Junk 486: Subject: Item #486: (Not a proposal) 486: Closed: Junk 487: Subject: Item #487: (Not a proposal) 487: Closed: Junk 488: Subject: Item #488: (Not a proposal) 488: Closed: Junk 489: Subject: Item #489: (Not a proposal) 489: Closed: Junk 490: Subject: Item #490: (Not a proposal) 490: Closed: Junk 491: Subject: Item #491: (Not a proposal) 491: Closed: Junk 492: Subject: Item #492: (Not a proposal) 492: Closed: Junk 493: Subject: Item #493: (Not a proposal) 493: Closed: Junk 494: Subject: Item #494: (Not a proposal) 494: Closed: Junk 495: Subject: Item #495: (Not a proposal) 495: Closed: Junk 496: Subject: Item #496: (Not a proposal) 496: Closed: Junk 497: Subject: Item #497: (Not a proposal) 497: Closed: Junk 498: Subject: Item #498: (Not a proposal) 498: Closed: Junk 499: Subject: Item #499: (Not a proposal) 499: Closed: Junk 500: Subject: Item #500: (Not a proposal) 500: Closed: Junk 501: Subject: Item #501: (Not a proposal) 501: Closed: Junk 502: Subject: Item #502: (Not a proposal) 502: Closed: Junk 503: Subject: Item #503: (Not a proposal) 503: Closed: Junk 504: Subject: Item #504: (Not a proposal) 504: Closed: Junk 505: Subject: Item #505: 505: Closed: Not a proposal 506: Subject: Item #506: 506: Closed: Not a proposal 507: Subject: Item #507: 507: Closed: Not a proposal 508: Subject: Item #508: 508: Closed: Not a proposal 509: Subject: Item #509: 509: Closed: Not a proposal 510: Subject: Item #510: 510: Closed: Not a proposal 511: Subject: Item #511: 511: Closed: Not a proposal 512: Subject: Item #512: 512: Closed: Not a Proposal 513: Subject: Item #513: 513: Closed: Not a proposal 514: Subject: Item #514: 514: Closed: Not a proposal 515: Subject: Item #515: 515: Closed: Not a proposal 516: Subject: Item #516: PCI-Express Binding to OF 516: New: not yet discussed